What sort of sector ETFs are available?

justETF.com

As always with ETFs it's important to know about the indices being tracked by sector ETFs in order to understand what you're buying into.

What sort of sector ETFs are available? Investors might turn to sector ETF investing to construct their portfolios in a different way to the more traditional geographic methodology, or to try to profit from the business cycle by betting on the sectors they believe are set to outperform, and underweighting the laggards.

Whatever your reasons for choosing sector ETFs, it's vital to know how they are invested – which as always with ETFs means understanding the indices being tracked by a sector ETFs' underlying holdings, and how those indices classify the tens of thousands of investable stocks available into different sectors.

 

Two sector classification schemes

The main providers of sector indices – MSCI and STOXX Limited – base their indices on one of two different internationally recognised sector classification schemes:
 
  • The Global Industry Classification Scheme (GICS), which divides 51,000 securities into 10 sectors, 24 industry groups, 67 industries and 156 sub-industries. 
  • The Industry Classification Benchmark (ICB), which classifies 75,000 securities into 10 industries, 19 supersectors, 41 sectors, and 114 subsectors.
 

GICS vs. ICB classification at a glance

GICS vs. ICB classification at a glance
Source: MSCI; ICB Benchmark; June 2015
   
STOXX Limited and FTSE use the ICB system as the basis for their indices, while MSCI and S&P employ GICS.

 

How the sector classification schemes work

Both schemes are based on a hierarchy of groupings – from broad sector classifications down to more specialist niches.
 
You can think of it as similar to how we classify the animal kingdom into family, genus, species and so on.

For example, companies (i.e. stocks) that derive the majority of their revenue from aerospace operations are placed by the ICB scheme…
 
  • … into the Aerospace Subsector
  • … which is part of the Aerospace and Defense Sector
  • … which is in the Industrial Goods and Services Supersector
  • … which sits within the Industrials Industry
Although the GICS system is similar – though certainly not identical – its category names are different. Hence there's the potential for investor confusion.

You can see that the top level under the GICS system is 'Sector', which is the third level of the hierarchy under the ICB system. Yet these are just labels – the ICB's 'Industry' level is functionally the same as the GICS 'Sector' level.
 
And of course commentators – including us – employ the word 'sector' to refer to all sorts of different industry groupings, not just to the specific meaning under the GICS or ICB methodologies.
 

Top level sectors/industries of GICS and ICB in comparison

GICS ICB Filter for ETFs
Energy Oil and Gas Show ETFs
Materials Basic Materials Show ETFs
Health Care Health Care Show ETFs
Industrials Industrials Show ETFs
Financials Financials Show ETFs
Information Technology Technology Show ETFs
Telecommunication Services Telecommunication Show ETFs
Utilities Utilities Show ETFs
Consumer Staples Consumer Goods Show ETFs
Consumer Discretionary Consumer Services Show ETFs

 
 

Up in the air

While the two classification schemes are superficially fairly similar, there are some real differences as you dig down into how they each categorize certain industries – and hence where those industries sit in their respective groupings.
 
  • For instance the ICB places Airlines in its Travel & Leisure Sector.
  • In contrast, the GICS system has Airlines in its Airlines Industry category, which is part of its Transportation Industry Group.
This isn't to say one categorization is better than the other – and clearly we can't go through all the differences between these systems here.
 
Rather, we want to highlight why you do need to thoroughly research an ETF before buying it to ensure it will correctly expose you to the performance of the kind of stocks you're looking for.
 
 

Sectors, regions, and optimized ETFs

In practical terms, while the deeper levels of the sector classification hierarchies are important to know about, only the higher levels of the GICS and ICB are actually investable through ETFs.
 
See the table below for an overview of what's currently available.
 
One more wrinkle is that sector ETFs come in regional and global flavours.
 
For example, db X-trackers has sector ETFs focused on the MSCI Emerging Markets base index, as well as MSCI World.
 
Again, please see the table below.
 
There are also sector ETFs that track 'optimized' and 'capped' versions of certain indices.
 
For instance Source offers sector ETFs based on the STOXX Europe 600 optimized index.
 
ETFs tracking these optimized indices may offer risk management benefits over ETFs that track standard indices, as they limit the total exposure the fund will have to any one company.
 
Investors may also prefer them for the potentially superior liquidity of their underlying holdings.

 

Finding the right sector ETF

justETF's screening tool will help you to find the ETF that's most appropriate to your needs.
 
You can use its drop-down filter to search for ETFs by sector and further restrict your search by region or country.
 
You can then research the different ETFs listed by noting what index they track and thus which classification scheme they're based on.
 
There are also convenient links to ETF factsheets, which will tell you more about how the ETF is invested and - where applicable - its top holdings.
 
All this research enables you to ensure you're buying the right product for your needs.
 

An overview of the range of sector ETFs

Region Base index Number of investable sectors on base index ETF provider Costs
Developed markets MSCI World 10 db X-trackers, Lyxor, Amundi 0.35% - 0.45%
Emerging markets MSCI Emerging markets 10 db X-trackers 0.65%
Europe STOXX Europe 600 10 + 8 sub sectors db X-trackers, iShares, Lyxor 0.30%- 0.50%
Europe STOXX Europe 600 Optimised 10 + 8 sub sectors Source 0.30%
Europe MSCI Europe 10 + 2 sub sectors SPDR, Amundi 0.25% - 0.30%
USA S&P Select Sector Capped 20% 9 Lyxor, Source 0.20% - 0.30%
China CSI 300 7 + 2 sub sectors db X-trackers 0.50%
Asia MSCI AC Asia Ex Japan 2 Lyxor 0.65%
Source: justETF.com; As of 06/07/15