A comparison of neobrokers: their strengths and weaknesses

Number of brokers: 2

We have tested the ETF offers of the most important online brokers for you.

Preliminary information:

We have reviewed the ETF offers of selected online brokers based on clearly defined criteria. Brokers with a strong focus on CFD trading, unclear or missing government regulation, or headquarters outside the EU were excluded. We regularly review this assessment.
This comparison is for information purposes only and does not constitute investment advice or a recommendation. Despite careful research, we do not guarantee the timeliness, accuracy, or completeness of the information provided. Past performance is not a reliable indicator of future results. Investments in securities involve risks, including total loss. Please check whether the products are suitable for your personal situation before making an investment decision.
Important note: We are part of the Scalable Group since 2021 and are a wholly owned subsidiary of Scalable GmbH. This means that we are economically connected, but operate with editorial independence. Conflicts of interest are avoided because brokers — including Scalable — are evaluated according to uniform, objective criteria. Ultimately, it’s up to you to decide how and with whom you want to invest.

Our evaluation process:

For each broker, we have examined the modalities for regular trading, the ETF savings plan offer and further criteria, such as automated tax reporting. In each category, we compared the offers of the online brokers with regard to different aspects and assessed them with points. In total, a maximum of 57 points could be attained. We then converted the number of points into a star rating, with 48 points being required for the maximum rating of 5.0 stars. The conversion of the number of points into stars is based on the formula: number of points achieved/10.

This results in the following rating scheme:

Points achieved	Stars	Evaluation
48 - 57	5 stars (4.8 - 5.0)	Outstanding
43 - 47	4.5 stars (4.3 - 4.7)	Very good
38 - 42	4 stars (3.8 - 4.2)	Very good
33 - 37	3.5 stars (3.3 - 3.7)	Good
28 - 32	3 stars (2.8 - 3.2)	Good
23 - 27	2.5 stars (2.3 - 2.7)	Satisfactory
18 - 22	2 stars (1.8 - 2.2)	Satisfactory
13 - 17	1.5 stars (1.3 - 1.7)	Adequate
8 - 12	1 star (0.8 - 1.2)	Adequate
3 - 7	0.5 star (0.3 - 0.7)	Poor
0 - 2	0 stars (0 - 0.2)	Poor

In the three categories mentioned above, we rated the broker offers as follows:

Trading (max. 25 points)

Fee for 1,000 € order (standard conditions)	Points
0.00 - 0.50 €	7
0.51 - 1.50 €	5.5
1.51 - 3.00 €	4
3.01 - 4.50 €	2.5
4.51 - 10.00 €	1
> 10.00 €	0

Fee for 10,000 € order (standard conditions)	Points
0.00 - 5.00 €	7
5.01 - 10.00 €	5.5
10.01 - 20.00 €	4
20.01 - 30.00 €	2.5
30.01 - 40.00 €	1
> 40.00 €	0

ETFs without order fee	Points
1,000+	5
750 - 999	4
500 - 749	3
250 - 499	2
1 - 249	1
0	0

Tradable assets (ETFs, stocks, funds, bonds, derivatives, crypto)	Points
1 point per tradable asset type	max. 6

Saving opportunities (max. 14 points)

ETF savings plan offer	Points
Points achieved in our ETF savings plan comparison multiplied by 14/41	max. 14

Service & Extras (max. 18 points)

Tax status	Points
Automated tax reporting	10
Tax report is provided (no automated reporting)	4
Neither automated reporting nor dedicated tax report	0

Account fee	Points
Free of charge (without conditions)	8
Free of charge (with conditions)	4
Account fee > 0 €	0

4.9

Outstanding

tested by justETF

Ordergebühr: 1.00 €

Depotgebühr: 0.00 €

Sparplan-Kosten: 0.00 €

New: 3% annual return on uninvested cash for new clients
Dedicated support: 24/7 phone support
Administered regime: Automatic tax management by the broker

Fee for 500 € order

1.00 €

View offer*

4.8

Outstanding

tested by justETF

Ordergebühr: 0.99 €

Depotgebühr: 0.00 €

ETFs ohne Kaufgebühr: 1,255

Sparplan-Kosten: 0.00 €

New: 2.5 % interest p.a. with a Scalable Overnight account
Free PACs: No fees for opening or managing accumulation plans
Customer service in Italian, available via chat and e-mail for fast and comprehensive assistance

Fee for 500 € order

0.99 €

View offer**

— The data was last updated on 19 May 2026
— The sorting by test result is done in the following order: 1. test result (points) 2. order fee 3. number of ETFs without purchase fee.
— In addition to the fees charged by online brokers, additional costs may apply. The stated fees are thus exclusive of standard market spreads, commissions, product costs and third-party fees.
— Please note: No guarantee can be given for the completeness, correctness and accuracy of the content listed. The information on the online brokers' homepages is decisive. Investments in securities involve risks.

* You want to open a securities account? If you use one of the affiliate links marked with an asterisk or the broker logos as a starting point, we will receive a commission. This is how we finance much of our free information offering. If you like our work, we appreciate your support!
** Important note: We are part of the Scalable Group since 2021 and are a wholly owned subsidiary of Scalable GmbH. This means that we are economically connected, but operate with editorial independence. Conflicts of interest are avoided because brokers — including Scalable — are evaluated according to uniform, objective criteria. You can view these in our . Ultimately, it’s up to you to decide how and with whom you want to invest.

Neobroker comparison 05/2026