Buffer ETFs: Which is the best?
How to invest in buffer ETFs
How to invest in buffer ETFs?
Buffer ETFs (also known as "Defined Outcome ETFs") offer investors the opportunity to participate in stock market performance while incorporating a precisely defined safety net against price losses. The mechanism is based on a combination of different options: The ETF buys protection (puts) to cushion losses up to a certain percentage (the "buffer"). To finance this protection, the ETF simultaneously sells call options (calls). This creates a clearly defined performance corridor for the return within a fixed period (usually one year). Investors give up a portion of potential upside gains in exchange for being shielded from moderate market declines.Performance Compared to the Benchmark
A buffer ETF performs very differently from its underlying index depending on the market phase:- Outperformance (moderate bear market): If the index falls within the defined buffer (e.g., up to -10%), the ETF’s value remains nearly stable. In this phase, the ETF significantly outperforms the benchmark because it does not participate in the losses.
- Protection in market crashes: If the market drops further than the built-in buffer (e.g., a 30% drop with a 10% buffer), the ETF will also lose value. However, the loss is reduced by exactly the buffer percentage compared to the index (in this example, a loss of only -20%).
- Underperformance (strong bull market): During phases of sharply rising prices, the ETF lags behind the benchmark. Since capital gains are "capped" by the sold options, you no longer participate in a rally once the fixed upper limit is reached.
Cboe S&P 500 15% WHT Quarterly 5% Buffer Protect performance
Buffer ETFs in comparison
When choosing a buffer ETF one should consider several other factors in addition to the methodology of the underlying index and performance of an ETF. For better comparison, you will find a list of all buffer ETFs with details on size, cost, age, income, domicile and replication method ranked by fund size.
Compare all buffer ETFs in detail
Compare all buffer ETFs in a chart
| ETF name ISIN | Fund size in m EUR | TER in % | Use of profits | Fund domicile | Replication method | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| First Trust Vest Nasdaq-100® Moderate Buffer UCITS ETF - June Class A USD ACCIE000HFBJ0U0 | 72 | 0,90% p.a. | Accumulerend | Ierland | Volledige replicatie | |
| First Trust Vest U.S. Equity Moderate Buffer UCITS ETF - May Class A USD ACCIE000P0FL8E3 | 34 | 0,85% p.a. | Accumulerend | Ierland | Volledige replicatie | |
| First Trust Vest U.S. Equity Moderate Buffer UCITS ETF - November Class A USD ACCIE000OJ31JQ4 | 33 | 0,85% p.a. | Accumulerend | Ierland | Volledige replicatie | |
| iShares US Large Cap Max Buffer Sep UCITS ETF USD (Acc)IE000ON9GR24 | 26 | 0,50% p.a. | Accumulerend | Ierland | Swap-gebaseerd | |
| iShares US Large Cap Deep Buffer UCITS ETF USD (Acc)IE000EOFR2K5 | 25 | 0,50% p.a. | Accumulerend | Ierland | Swap-gebaseerd | |
| First Trust Vest U.S. Equity Moderate Buffer UCITS ETF - February Class A USD ACCIE000X8M8M80 | 23 | 0,85% p.a. | Accumulerend | Ierland | Volledige replicatie | |
| iShares US Large Cap Max Buffer Dec UCITS ETF USD (Acc)IE000Y1595P8 | 19 | 0,50% p.a. | Accumulerend | Ierland | Swap-gebaseerd | |
| iShares US Large Cap Max Buffer Mar UCITS ETF USD (Acc)IE000INTB8Q8 | 16 | 0,50% p.a. | Accumulerend | Ierland | Volledige replicatie | |
| iShares US Large Cap Moderate Buffer Dec UCITS ETF (Acc)IE000Z5YU8X3 | 16 | 0,50% p.a. | Accumulerend | Ierland | Swap-gebaseerd | |
| First Trust Vest U.S. Equity Moderate Buffer UCITS ETF - August Class A USD ACCIE000TGSG3Y5 | 16 | 0,85% p.a. | Accumulerend | Ierland | Volledige replicatie | |
| iShares US Large Cap Moderate Buffer Mar UCITS ETF USD (Acc)IE000AY2ERH5 | 15 | 0,50% p.a. | Accumulerend | Ierland | Volledige replicatie | |
| Global X S&P 500 Quarterly Tail Hedge UCITS ETF USD AccumulatingIE000EPX8KB7 | 11 | 0,50% p.a. | Accumulerend | Ierland | Niet-gefinancierde swap | |
| First Trust Vest Nasdaq-100® Moderate Buffer UCITS ETF - September Class A USD ACCIE000FQ808R5 | 9 | 0,90% p.a. | Accumulerend | Ierland | Volledige replicatie | |
| First Trust Vest Nasdaq-100® Moderate Buffer UCITS ETF - December Class A USD ACCIE000GAKWFA7 | 9 | 0,90% p.a. | Accumulerend | Ierland | Volledige replicatie | |
| Global X S&P 500® Quarterly Buffer UCITS ETF USD AccumulatingIE000LSRKCB4 | 7 | 0,50% p.a. | Accumulerend | Ierland | Niet-gefinancierde swap | |
| First Trust Vest U.S. Equity Buffer UCITS ETF - April Class A USD ACCIE000WX2HZQ7 | 7 | 0,85% p.a. | Accumulerend | Ierland | Volledige replicatie | |
| First Trust Vest U.S. Equity Buffer UCITS ETF - January Class A USD ACCIE000MDKBOB3 | 4 | 0,85% p.a. | Accumulerend | Ierland | Volledige replicatie | |
| First Trust Vest U.S. Equity Max Buffer UCITS ETF - June Class A AccumulationIE000CO3P697 | 3 | 0,85% p.a. | Accumulerend | Ierland | Volledige replicatie | |
| First Trust Vest U.S. Equity Buffer UCITS ETF - October Class A USD ACCIE0004X8KUG5 | 2 | 0,85% p.a. | Accumulerend | Ierland | Volledige replicatie | |
| First Trust Vest U.S. Equity Buffer UCITS ETF - July Class A USD ACCIE000YJBT6I5 | 2 | 0,85% p.a. | Accumulerend | Ierland | Volledige replicatie | |
| First Trust Vest U.S. Equity Max Buffer UCITS ETF - September Class A AccumulationIE0009DRFET8 | 1 | 0,85% p.a. | Accumulerend | Ierland | Volledige replicatie | |
| First Trust Vest US Equity Max Buffer UCITS ETF - March Class A USD ACCIE0002PPCMH6 | 1 | 0,85% p.a. | Accumulerend | Ierland | Volledige replicatie | |
| Global X S&P 500 Annual Buffer UCITS ETF USD AccumulatingIE0009BM62P2 | 1 | 0,50% p.a. | Accumulerend | Ierland | Niet-gefinancierde swap | |
| First Trust Vest Nasdaq-100® Moderate Buffer UCITS ETF - March Class A USD ACCIE0006S0EBF2 | 1 | 0,90% p.a. | Accumulerend | Ierland | Volledige replicatie | |
| Global X S&P 500 Annual Tail Hedge UCITS ETF USD AccumulatingIE000HGH8PV2 | 1 | 0,50% p.a. | Accumulerend | Ierland | Niet-gefinancierde swap |
Source: justETF.com; As of 23-05-2026
Return comparison of all buffer ETFs
The table shows the returns of all buffer ETFs in comparison. All return figures are including dividends as of month end. Besides the return the reference date on which you conduct the comparison is important. In order to find the best ETFs, you can also perform a chart comparison.
Source: justETF.com; As of 30-04-2026; Calculations in EUR including dividends
